Book 5 discussion due by July 20th

Book 5

Book 5

by Miranda Cummings -
Number of replies: 0
I'm REALLY sorry this is so late. I had band camp last week and LEADERSHIP CAMP this week! (which was AMAZING)
OK! I am THRILLED that Lise and Alyosha decided to get married! Every since she wrote him that letter I knew they would get together eventually! I though it was nice to see another side of Smerdyakov, when he was singing to that girl. I didn't like the girl he was singing to though, I found it stupid when she was telling him that she wanted him to get in a duel over her. What a silly girl. I enjoyed the brothers conversation about God, it gave a lot of insight in to the reason why Ivan is the way he is. I didn't like how he mentioned that loving god is like a person being tortured loving his tourer. I got really nervous at end of this book because of what happened to Smerdyakov and that Fyodor is now alone. But I guess it would be ok if he died, because I still don't like him. That sounds really mean. Again, sorry this is so late!