Book 3 discussion

Book 3

Book 3

by Shelby Woodby -
Number of replies: 4

I kind of feel bad for Lizaveta. Everyone thinks bad of her, just because she's slow. So was Sam Dawson! But he had a baby...that's such a good movie =) But I guess that was nice of Gregory and his wife to take the baby in. They seem like they've had enough experience with that, anyway.

But I couldn't believe that Alyosha actually went to visit Katerina! I mean, I don't think he intended to do anything with her...it just, didn't seem his character. So I was kind of thrown off-guard. But then when Dmitri found him...it was like a soap opera moment. At least that's what I think. Dmitri's such a manwhore. At least he feels somewhat guilty about it though.

And I'd like to join in on Gregory and Smerdyakov's debate. I don't agree with Smerdyakov- you should never renounce your faith in God. If you did, then I don't think you even had any faith to begin with. And yes, you can ask for forgiveness later, but that's so selfish. I don't see how Fyodor could get sick of such a heated argument. And when Fyodor started attacking Alyosha with mean words about his mother, I felt so angry with him! Well he shouldn't have gotten her pregnant if he thinks she's so bad! I mean this was such a dramatic moment in the book for me, especially when Dmitri came and started flipping out about Grushenka (who names their child Grushenka??!).

I think Grushenka and Katerina are like two little children. Grushenka only wanted to stay with Dmitri because Katerina was excited to possibly have him back (I don't know why). I wouldn't want to be someone's last resort, though.

This book had some ups and downs- some exciting parts and some long, drawn-out, exceedingly BORING snoozefest parts. But the author accomplished his goal in getting his point across, and in getting a reaction out of the reader- me. I definitely felt upset at times, like when Fyodor was speaking mean things about Alyosha and Ivan's mother. But I also felt a little happy when Alyosha read Lise's love letter; that was cuuute :)

Ok I'm done now so bye.

In reply to Shelby Woodby

Re: Book 3

by Marlene Azar -
I agree with you about the argument between Gregory and Smerdyakov.  It's almost like cheating if you renounce your faith to save your life, just because you think God will forgive you later.  I think Smerdyakov is a wierd person, especially because of what the book told us about his childhood (i.e. killing cats, secluding himself, ect.).
In reply to Shelby Woodby

Re: Book 3

by Victoria Bunker -

Hey Shelby!

I very much agree with you about the whole Gregory and Smerdyakov agrument.If you were to renounce your faith in the hour of the greatest need for it you would be no better than Judas who betrayed Jesus leading to his cruixifixtion( not spelled right at all sorry!) I also dislike Smerdyakov, and i definitely don't blame Gregory for his dislike of the kid either he seems to get the same sick pleasure out of manipulating and tricking people that Grushenka does.  

In reply to Shelby Woodby

Re: Book 3

by Anjalika Lobo -
That's what I think too.  It seems like if you just expect God to forgive you, you were never sorry in the first place.